Rated 4 out of 5 by Noey Great liner
I really love the formula for these liners as well as the color selection. They have a very fluid consistency which is a bit difficult after you apply it because you can't really blink until it sets. I tried using this on my water line, bad idea since I'm not exactly a pro with eyeliner and I got some in my eye, whoa did that sting. I do wish it had more in the tube, when I got I I was disappointed to see that the larger part was only the handle so I don't think I would pay full price for these. But I was able to get 3 of them with their current price so I'm glad
September 12, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by love25 Not good at all
Ok, I really think that I may have gotten a bad batch of this eyeliner. Before buying it, I have read all of the raging reviews and was super excited to try this liner. The one that I received does not apply well at all. It has an oily/watery consistency and I have to dip the brush at least 5-6 times in order to get a good dark line on my lid and even that happens rarely. I always have to fill in my wing with another eyeliner that's not liquid in order to fill in the gaps. Overall, I wouldn't purchase this again. But once again, I feel like I received an expired product because the quality of this eyeliner is so bad. I've never had an urban decay product this bad before. Need to shop for another liquid liner ASAP.
August 5, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jmommabear Only eyeliner I will ever use!
Now let me tell you before I ever tried using this liquid eyeliner I thought I hate liquid eyeliners. Their brushes were funky and the formula they used would sting my eyes! And then I received this in the book of shadows 4 and thought "hey I should at least give it a try". And I fell in love at first use! It is so easy to use, the brush Is perfect ebro if you just want to draw a thin line. The formula doesn't sting my eyes and the color variety is amazing! I have this in perversion, retrograde and radium! I love double lining my eyes. The colors are so vibrant!
January 31, 2012
Rated 4 out of 5 by witchypoet Fabulous revamp of the best eyeliner out there!
I do love the ease of application with the new liquid eyeliner. The old bottle dried out quickly and the brush got goopy after a bit. This new design eliminates those issues and allows me to get a super-thin, precise line with ease. Like the old liquid liner, this stuff stays on! I'm an eye-rubber and UD liquid liner is the only brand that is still on my eyes by the end of the day. The color selections are, as expected with UD, incredible. I'm very happy to see gray offered at last!
The only con to this product is that the pigment could be more vivid. I didn't get any of the jewel tones yet, just gray and black, so this may vary with color. The shades are just a bit subtle. Urban Decay isn't supposed to be subtle!
November 22, 2011
Rated 4 out of 5 by Nicole789456123hdhhdnrnhd literally PEELED off
I'm just going to start with the fact that this liner literally peels off your eyes. What the heck! It's waterproof I guess and it does take some work to remove, but hey!.. what else could you expect.
I purchased the color smog because it is featured in one off the naked pallets. It's one of my favorite colors among all of the naked pallets. This color is WAY off. Despite the fact it doesn't match, the color is still beautifully paired with my blue eyes.
Despite these flaws, I wound still recommend this product because of the gorgeous color and the great staying power.
December 15, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by txrx so close....
These colors are absolutely fantastic, and I was so thrilled to find such a great dark navy color (Sabbath) and I was so excited to try retrograde as well. In my opinion, the brush is pretty much perfect. It is indeed thin, but I think that makes it even easier to use, especially if you want to be more artistic with your liner.
Unfortunately, however, this does not stay on well. It cracks and flakes off. When compared to the pencil liner that I can sleep in and it still looks good, I am extremely disappointed that this has been flaking within 2 hours of putting it on.
October 3, 2011
Rated 5 out of 5 by MsCookieTea Fun with the stay power
You can't go wrong with these long lasting, fun colors. This is a easy way to amp up a natural look or add that extra something to an already bold look. I originally purchased these during the summer time for the purpose of being able to go to the beach without worrying about the it wearing off. And it definitely doesn't go any where. I use these all the time regardless of where I'm going. The brush allows you to create thin intricate details. But that brush may not be for every one as some may prefer working with a sponge tip. It could take some practice & worth it.
February 29, 2012
Rated 1 out of 5 by corrz flakey :(
I'm so sad! I've been wanting this eyeliner for ever!
I love everything UD and I couldnt wait to try this liner. I went to two stores to find Sabbath.
I don't know if its my eyelids or what is going on,
but after a few hours of wear, when I tried to touch up my mascara,
It flakes off in a spot. So I just touched my eyeliner and
A huge hunk came off. needless to say,
I looked pretty weird all day long.
only positive is I didn't have to wash
it off because it already flaked off totally by the end of the day.
I'm Sooooo sad. I looooved the color and pigment!
July 31, 2013
Rated 1 out of 5 by CATT Disappointed
I've been using the Urban Decay eyeliner for years and haven't be happier. But when I went in to get the usual black eyeliner from them they stopped making it!! So I figured that this would be the same eyeliner but water proof. The color doesn't come out properly every time (yes i do shake it well) I have noticed it leaves patches where the eyeliner was applied. I usually do a cat eye. It not so easy to take off, especially when it gets onto my eyelashes, almost like black rubber. I miss the old eyeliner and will have to be changing the line of eyeliner I use. :(
October 17, 2011
Rated 5 out of 5 by AnaNaru PERVERSION: The Holy Grail of Liquid Liners
I am beyond words to decribe how perfect this eyeliner in the color Perversion really is.
The application is flawless and as easy as it could be thanks to the applicator is packs. The best by far in all the beauty market - and I've tried almost all from drugstore to high-end ones and compared.
The formula lasts all day long and is not too dense nor not too fluid; just perfect. The black is on spot, not too dark and not light either - suits everyday work needs and glam nights as well.
I'm head over heels for this eyeliner and it has a special place in my heart.
March 22, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by CatsMeow A must have in your arsenal of shiny things!
i didn't use this for a couple days after I received it on my eyes but I did apply it to the top of my hand the day I got it to see how well it would wear through my work week (I bartend so my hand are constantly wet and being washed). Now I know the skin on your eyes and hands wear differently but OMG it is definitely waterproof! It lasted the whole day through showering and dishes and wiping my hands on towels. The color and shine is just the right amount on first application and if you want to go extra glam, a second application is just as easy and effective.
July 4, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by mjjcollectors Wonderful and Eay To Use!
I love this eyeliner 'cos up to now I really couldn't use any that made me happy so I ended using only waterproof eye pencils. My main issue was other eye liners I tried were hard to use and the line came out very badly. I tried this one by UD and I was amazed 'cos very easy to use and being waterproof you don't have to get worried if some dust enter in your eyes, some tears come down for using contact lenses etc.. because your make-up will be intact and always glam all the day long! UD is very very amazing and little by little I want to buy all of your products!
April 26, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by AmberGloom My Holy Grail Liquid Eyeliner
I have VERY oily and hooded lids. I love wearing dramatic eyeliner, but I always got a transfer of color from my lash line to the brow bone, even when I use an eye shadow primer AND a setting spray. I don't with this eye liner! IT'S AMAZING. It seems to work similar to tubing mascaras, once it's dry it only comes off with warm water and it sort of peels off in one piece. There is no fading, it lasts all day (ALL DAY), even for oily eyelids! The brush is nice too, very thin and flexible, and the formula goes on super smooth. Best liquid eye liner ever.
February 18, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by MCN23 ABSOLUTELY A MUST HAVE !
Sooooo Again I Got This ON SALE FOR SIX DOLLARS ! There's One Review That Says It's Clumpy And What Not but Girl you must have done something wrong to yours because mine is absolutely AMAZING ! I LOVE IT LOVE LOVE LOVE IT ! It glides on Soo smoothly Stays on and you can make the perfect wing YES PERFECT! I always had problems doing my eyeliner to where I just lined the top and never did a wing BUT AS SOON AS I GOT THIS IT WAS LIKE WING WEDNESDAY EVERYDAY lol It's just beautiful and awesome so awesome I ordered it in the black and grey with sparkles ! And I can't wait to have it come Plus I used my kick back and I only paid a DOLLAR SOMETHING FOR IT YES ONLY ONE DOLLAR !!!!!!! I LOOOOOOOOVVVVVEEEEE URBAN DECAY NOTHING COMES ABOVE !
September 16, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by MireSnow30 Great eyeliners, love the stay power!!!
I love the 24/7 liquid eyeliners. The brush can be a little tricky for those who are not used to using such a flexible and thin eyeliner tip. I have experience and I only found it to be a problem a few times. I like how you can put a few dots and smudge it to make it look smokey! The stay power is fantastic on these liners but taking it off is a little difficult thats why I put 4 out of 5 stars. It sort of peels off and can come off in one piece. In a way it is suppposed to because they are waterproof. Once it peels off though you are good. I am really happy with these eyeliners and they are great when I really want staying power. I also like the tip because you can do super thin lines or really thick lines. I love Urban Decay!
April 27, 2012
Rated 3 out of 5 by Jazzy391 Love the colors and the application but some drawbacks
I was so excited when I put on this liner. The colors look amazing and it goes on really easily. The only drawbacks I noticed were first of all, the bottle. The piece that separates the brush from the pigment pulled out and it makes it very difficult to get the excess liner oll of the brush. The biggest negative though was the staying power. The liner looks great when you first put it on but then begins to flake and peel. I can actually peel the entire line off in one piece. Using the primer potion helps a bit but as the night goes on, I still notice peeling and flaking. The only good part about the peeling is that if it starts happening, I can just peel the line off and reapply without having to take the rest of my eye makeup off.
January 31, 2012
Rated 2 out of 5 by Asphodel23 This eyeliner is NOT good
I use a lot of eyeliner, so I was so excited to try this one. All of these positive reviews had me convinced I would love it. I was wrong. Instead of smearing like other eyeliner, this one crumbles. It crumbles off after just a few hours. The crumbles get in my eyes and down my face.
I will say one thing. A lot of people are saying that this eyeliner is not forgiving if you make a mistake. I did not find this to be true. You can correct mistakes with it easily.
Overall, I was seriously disappointed in this product and I will never buy it again. :(
July 29, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by Bekka For eyes that POP
I greatly prefer liquid liner to any other liner, so I was happy have the opportunity to try this product. I am very happy with the long handle (offers great control), and the super-fine brush applicator (for razor-thin lining). I absolutely LOVE the finish of Perversion: it dries with the most gorgeous, wet, patent-leather shine. Finally, this is not a product where "waterproof" means "water-resistant". This really is WATERPROOF. Removing your liner can be quite difficult (I use a petroleum-based salve to dissolve it, which works fine).
The only thing I can say I don't like about this product is the price. It is very, very spendy for an eyeliner. However, the performance makes it worth the splurge. I would buy this again and again.
February 29, 2012
Rated 3 out of 5 by Skylord It's ok
"24/7?? Waterproof?? Eyeliner with a thin applicator? $6?! Bet. I'm buying this right now" My exact inner dialogue as I came across this little item. Needless to say I was very excited to receive this liquid eyeliner. However, I wasn't very thrilled after using the product. The formula was very watery and when I tried to apply it no color transferred onto my eyelid. Instead it was just a watery, gray liquid, not the black eyeliner I was expecting. The applicator is nice and thin, so things are kept nice and sharp. Overall I'm not a huge fan just because it has been a hot or Miss whenever I try to use this. I keep going back to my cheap, not watery, liquid eyeliner. You win some, you lose some for this price. I still love Urban Decay though!
September 3, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by jayleigh Best Liquid Liner
This is hands down the best liquid liner I have ever used. I've purchased high end liners & cheap ones. Nothing can compare to these liners. Your search is over, Perversion is absolutely the best black liquid liner ever. So easy to use whether you're doing a thin line or thick cat eye look. Lasts forever without primer. Dries fast. Once dry it never smudges off. True to what it says, these babies are waterproof. Besides Perversion, my favorites are Sabbath (great navy alternative to black#, Retrograde # awesome purple not too sparkly#, Siren #beautiful teal- it makes a nude shadow look pop#, Smog #great neutral# Demolition #another great liner for a more neutral look). Buy one or all you will not be disappointed. Highest quality you can find.
August 9, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by cherylmarie Yay! Finally found an eyeliner that lasts all day!!!!
I got this in Perversion with the book of shadows. I have used an abundance of eyeliners. Most of them claim to be waterproof, and by the end of the day they fade or the outer corners of my eyes start to run. I haven't used many liquid liners, but a few. I was using a lot of waterproof cream liners. I also find this liner very easy to apply, I love how small the brush is and I can build the line to how thick I want it. I don't like the pen type applicator. I am so happy with this, I will definitely be purchasing more, and maybe try some other colors.
March 9, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by Celi The Perfect Eyeliner.
I'm so pleased with this product! The ease of use makes every line look professionally done, and makes slip ups easy to fix, due to the shape and size of the brush. The formula is AMAZING! I can't say enough about how perfect it is. Yes, it is certainly water proof, however it comes off as easily as a normal liquid liner, if not easier; when cleanser is added, the formula literally peels of, no smudging, no scrubbing, or special remover required. The staying power is also AMAZING. I've worked 10 hour days with this on and it still looks as fresh as it did in the morning. the original price may seem a little pricey for the size, but a little goes a long way. I've had a tube for 4 months, which i use regularly and it's still going strong!
August 19, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by QUEENk23 Irresistible Eyes
I bought this liner in demolition (brown), but every color selection for this product is great! I want to collect them all to be honest. The application was easy and ran smoothly on my eyes. The color was very pigmented and lasted the whole day. Waterproof is a wonderful feature, but can be annoying when it comes to product removal. It dries instantly and doesn't run/smear. I also bought this for my friend as a gift and she loved it! In conclusion, can't go wrong with this liner!! High quality, great value, and makes a wonderful gift.
September 25, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Cindybell Stay allday
My sister order me the black one and I love it, I'm very picky about liquid liners I love the brush were you have the option to make the line thin or thick as you want love the handle just right to hold the liner but most of all I like the formula , I usually do the top and the bottom liner of my eyes and I always have issues with the bottom liner were sometimes after a couple hours the liner smears not this one it stays in place and I love when I do the bottom it doesn't get into my lower lashes . I love this product will be buying .
September 3, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by lucy87 worst liquid liner ever!!!!
I wanted this liner for a long time and finally bought it for myself as a Xmas gift in January. When I first got it I loved it! The color payoff was great n I loved that it is waterproof. After a couple of weeks passed it completely dried out!!! I was so disappointed so I called sephora and the girl told me it might be a bad one. I went and exchanged it n she asked if I wanted to get a different brand and I said no because I love the color so I got the same 24/7 liquid liner in perversion (I really wanted it to work) and to my surprise it dried up after a couple of weeks too! I have other UD products and loved them but not this one! I was so sad this 2 liners dried out! I'm happy if it works for a lot of u just wished it had worked for me :(
July 16, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by Makeup07 My go to
Love tgis liquid liner it's my go to I always reach for this liner and i love how smoothly it glides on. It's stays on all day amd does t smudge.
September 27, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Eloise Not waterproof.
I'm a massive urban decay fan and own a tone of their products. These eyeliners are total cra*. Being a person that has crazy hayfever all year round, a waterproof eyeliner is my best friend! Because of my hayfever my eyes water constantly. I own this in black and the brown shade and I can't even make it out the door without this liner coming off. Not that it begins dripping, it simply becomes a patchy mess, almost becomes a rubber texture lifts from the skin and then just peels off. Hands down worst 'waterproof' eyeliner ever! Although I like the brush so 1/5 for me. If you have watery eyes don't even bother with this product. If you are a normal joe that doesn't have eye issues then you will probably love it because it shouldn't get wet....
February 18, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by the3arthchild No Regret Eyeliner!!
I am wowed again by how long lasting Urban Decay's products are and how great they look! I used to show this product on my hand all the time when I worked at a cosmetics store and it would take a day or two to get the liner completely off the back of my hand. Imagine on your eyes then!! It will take a little practice getting used to the flexible tip but it creates beautiful lines and it's easy to play up once you're a pro! The only problem I encountered with this product was the little cone that the brush came out of broke so I got a new one.
March 5, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sly4ya The anti-liquid eyeliner user's liquid eyeliner
I absolutely hated using liquid eyeliner...I never understood it's purpose. So when I purchased the book of shadows 4 and it came with one in "Perversion", I figured what the heck, it came with it, so I tried it. Now I can't figure out why I hated the stuff so much to begin with. I have since purchased another one in "Demolition". This is a must have for anyone serious about making their eyes pop with some liquid eyeliner. The selection of colors is amazing, and I can't wait to explore my creative side and buy some of the "brighter" colors. I rated all 5 stars except ease of use because it's still a liquid eyeliner, and it can be tricky, however, the long brush used for application is one of the better ones I've seen on any liquid eyeliner.
February 3, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by browneyedbarbie Amazing eyeliner
I bought the liners in Eldorado and Retrograde. When I purchased the eyeliners I was skeptical of Eldorado and whether I would like it or not. I am SO GLAD I purchased it. It has quickly become a staple in my makeup routine, and I get many compliments on it.
I was so impressed when I first opened the liners and swatched them on the back of my hand at how gorgeous the colors were, and overnight while I was sleeping the liner didn't budge; in fact, it didn't come off until about 24 hours or more later, even with normal wear and tear that your hands go through daily.
One thing though is that it doesn't seem to be completely waterproof if it gets quite wet and you rub it, it'll peel right off. It does make for easy removal at the end of the day though.
March 31, 2016