If you love the extra-thickening powers of Big Fatty Mascara, round out your collection with these wearable shades. Turquoise and navy hues give brown and blue eyes a jolt, purple shades make green eyes more dangerous, and burgundy adds drama to any eye color—a refreshing alternative to basic black.

A smaller version of the beloved Big Fatty Mascara tube, Color Mascaras still feature a big, fuzzy brush for insane volume. And, each is wrapped in a color-coordinated Pucci-inspired print! The creamy formula, infused with hemp oil, Vitamin E, Shea Butter, and Jojoba Oil, thickens and lengthens lashes. Try it once and you’ll be addicted.