Rated 5 out of 5
by Dacia Better Than Anything I've Ever Tried!
For me, mascara is one of those "must-haves" for me. I have light brown lashes that are very sparse, medium in length and mostly stick-straight. I've been a fan of UD for many years now, but for some reason never tried any of their mascaras, choosing to stick either to drug store brands or more "well established" brands like Dior, which never left my eyelashes looking like I wanted them to! But today, something happened. I bought the new Book of Shadows IV, and decided to try out the mascara. I wasn't too thrilled with the brush, as the curved brushes never seem to ACTUALLY curl the lashes... and the plasticy bristles tend to leave clumps on my eyelashes, but this mascara has proven all of my prejudices WRONG!
My lashes have the most amazing curl. They actually curl up and touch my upper lids... and they're so beautifully defined, look fluffy and full, and even stayed put when I got a little teary-eyed trying to get a picture of my lashes to show my friends the results (yes, I love this product so much already that I'm telling ALL of my friends, including make-up artists, about this).
For all its awesome staying power, it does come off really well with some gentle eye makeup remover! I would (and already AM) recommending this product to anyone and everyone I know!
This mascara is great with a single coat for a natural look, but the formula is so smooth, you can layer it on for some serious drama. I think I continuously applied coats for a minute each eye just to see how long it would take to start getting super clumpy lashes... Never once did I get a huge glob of mascara, and it even defined my stubby lower lashes and made them look long! I think the beeswax is what makes the formula so nice :)
the picture I took doesn't do the curl justice... trying to take a picture from the side
September 7, 2011
Rated 4 out of 5
by SimplySweetness Easy to please? Maybe but I love this mascara!
I have tried almost every drugstore brand there is, and have yet to find that perfect one! I got this as a sample in the Book of Shadows 4 and I have to say, so far I am impressed!!
The color is very dark and I love it!
It doesn't curl much but i'm sure with the help of a eyelash curler, it would be perfect. I have very small, light and straight lashes. This gave them great length and with 3 or 4 swipes, it didn't clump. The brush is stiff, which is a plus to keep clumps away. Not to mention my lashes are still soft after applying and not dry, at all!
December 2, 2011
Rated 3 out of 5 by Kacey527 Good quality mascara, but did not curl my lashes at all
I have very straight eyelashes - i always curl them with a curler and use waterproof mascara because it holds the curl (most regular mascaras straighten my lashes back out). This got good reviews so I decided to give it a try, but I was disappointed that it straightened my lashes just like all other regular mascaras. However, I love how dark the pigmentation is, and it gives a little more volume and length without being clumpy. It just really defines your lashes and makes them stand out. It's also really long lasting and didn't smudge or flake at all (even after sleeping in it?) I'm going to try layering it over my waterproof mascara.
February 2, 2012
Rated 3 out of 5 by Lizz27 Wish it was Waterproof
I loved this mascara at first! My lashes looked amazing and it was so simple and all it took was one sweep, BAM. It looked like I was wearing falsies! However, this formula isn't waterproof and I really wish it was! I live in texas and from all the sweat or me tearing up during allergy season, this stuff runs and smears so easily like no other. I tried putting a primer on (not Urban Decay) and it still ran, I still have this mascara and use it for dinner nights out. When I wont be sweating or anything and the evening is cool. I really want a waterproof version though! I would be in heaven!
February 16, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by Fujeyckei Fav. Mascara!
When it comes to buying Mascara, I don't care too much about lengthing or volumizing my lashes (hence the fact that I'm Asian and I'm one of those unfortunate Asian with like, 10 lashes on each eye lol) so all I really do focus on is a mascara that'll hold up my curls. I've been on the hunt for a mascara that'll hold them up for the longest time and this... THIS.. IT'S AMAZING! Does a great job on holding them up all day. I was skeptical at first but as the day carried on and I kept looking at my lashes, they were holding up really nice. By far, my ultimate fav. mascara! :) Although I don't care for length or volume, I must say this does a decent job on it as well and it's not clumpy :)
February 7, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by Rosie88 Overall Excellent Mascara
I had been using Lancome's curling formula mascara before giving this a try. Supercurl is definitely as good, if not better, and it's $5 cheaper.
-Excellent curl, length, and definition
-Good lash thickness with 2 coats
-Deep black pigment
-Very little flaking (just a few tiny flakes after 6 hours of wear)
-Smaller brush allows more precise application (Lancome's thick brush tends to get mascara on my skin.)
-Curl falls quite a bit a few hours after application. This is also somewhat true of the Lancome formula, but the Lancome seems to hold the curl a bit better over time.
Also, keep in mind I do not use an eyelash curler. If you do, it might help the curl hold up longer.
August 7, 2011
Rated 5 out of 5 by mymaserati Overall wonderful product
FINALLY, an Urban Decay mascara I can get behind! I've tried Big Fatty and wasn't impressed and both Skyscraper formulas/brushes and didn't like them. This is a totally different product. The packaging is elegant and beautiful. The formula removes very easily but never flakes. The brush is very easy to use, and helps apply the product evenly(!) and quickly.
With this mascara it takes no time to get curled, lengthened lashes. I normally use an eyelash curler and with this I don't really need to. Although the curl isn't as perfect as you'd get carefully using an eyelash curler, the curl is very noticeable and the formula holds the curl all day. Very high quality product, I'm very impressed. I will definitely buy this product again.
July 27, 2011
Rated 5 out of 5 by Georgia My HG mascara!
After trying many mascaras that didnt work for me, I finally found my Holy Grail mascara. The problem is that I have stubborn straight lashes that would lose its curl after using an eyelash curler and applying mascara. I love that the Supercurl mascara does everything I would want a mascara to do. It gives volume, length and it holds a curl perfectly. It doesnt irritate my sensitive eyes and I dont get raccoon eyes at the end of the day. Although, it is a bit pricey, its definitely worth the money.
July 1, 2011